Why is Justice Taney’s argument ineffective?

A latest school question and answer enquired students to assert what they assume is the most important factor for a student to do in order to obtain success. The one that response stood out from the rest was practice. People who definitely successful do not become successful by being born. They work hard and perseverance their lives to succeeding. This is how you can fulfill your goals. just below some question and answer examples that you could definitely use to improve your knowledge and gain insight that will guide you to maintain your school studies.

Question:

Why is Justice Taney’s argument ineffective?

Read the passage from the opinion of the court in Dred
Scott v. Sandford, written by Justice Taney.
He uses the freedom of African Americans as evidence.
He uses a previous status of African Americans as
evidence.
He uses the dissenting argument of the court as
evidence
He uses the ruling of the previous court as evidence.
The question then arises, whether the provisions of the
Constitution, in relation to the personal rights and
privileges to which the citizen of a State should be entitled,
embraced the negro African race, at that time in this
country, or who might afterwards be imported, who had
then or should afterwards be made free in any State; and
to put it in the power of a single State to make him a
citizen of the United States, and endue him with the full
rights of citizenship in every other State without their
consent? Does the Constitution of the United States act
upon him whenever he shall be made free under the laws
of a State, and raised there to the rank of a citizen, and
immediately clothe him with all the privileges of a citizen in
every other State, and in its own courts?
The court thinks the affirmative of these propositions

READ MORE  Definition: This is the actions of organisms in response to stimuli.

Answer:

The reason why Justice Taney’s argument was ineffective was that He uses a previous status of African Americans as evidence.

What did Justice Taney do?

In Dred Scott v. Sandford, Justice Taney used the fact that African Americans were once entirely enslaved to base his argument against granting citizenship to African Americans.

This was ineffective because African Americans were no longer entirely enslaved and could be free which meant that they could also assume citizenship rights.

From the answer and question examples above, hopefully, they might be able to assist the student take care of the question they had been looking for and observe of all declared in the answer above. Then would probably make some sharing in a group discussion and also study with the classmate in connection with the topic, so another student also experience some enlightenment and still keeps up the school learning.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.